Scheuchzer called the stone “the most remarkable of all the oddities of all museums.” He studied both legends and first-hand witness accounts of dragon sightings, compiling what he called “a description of Swiss dragons by canton as they can be obtained from printed and handwritten testimonies and reports.” When he heard of purported dragon remains, he examined the physical evidence, but everything he found appeared to be from recognizable animals, like bears.
Despite the unconfirmed sightings, he published these stories in his scientific treatise, the Itinera Alpina, along with illustrations. While he could not corroborate the existence of dragons through physical evidence, he believed the people he interviewed to be trustworthy and considered their accounts to be vetted by virtue of their character:
Towards the end of summer 1717 […] Joseph Scherer from Näfels […] came across an animal with a cat's head and protruding eyes. It was a foot long and had a thick body and four feet. Two teat-like structures hung from its lower abdomen. It also had a tail, whose length was a foot, and the entire creature was scaly and colorful. Scherer struck the animal with a pointed stick, and he claimed that it was soft and full of toxic blood, so that when a drop fell on his leg, it swelled.
In 1811, nearly 80 years after Scheuchzer's death, French comparative anatomist Georges Cuvier, also called the "Father of Paleontology", proved that Homo Diluvii Testis was, in fact, an ichthyosaur. Twenty years later, the giant salamander was renamed the Salamandra Scheuchzeri, and in 1837, it was added to the newly created genus Andrias, a family of foul-smelling creatures with vicious teeth and rough, mottled skin, as the Andrias Scheuchzeri.